Admiral Buzzkill wrote:
Trek fans have been making excuses for bad storytelling since the 1960's.
That doesn't make it right!
make attempts to compare nuTrek unfavorably to oldTrek wrong
on this score.
Frankly, someone could come along and produce an Oscar-winning Star Trek
film that was internationally hailed as a masterpiece and knocked Avatar
off to become the most successful film in history...and some trek fans would call it "an okay film but bad Star Trek
" because it was different
and didn't respect "canon."
(Okay, that's obviously a hypothetical - I don't think anyone could produce an Oscar-caliber Trek movie.)
But Star Trek (2009) did win an Oscar, and was nominated for three more.