Well I've only taken part in the last 2.
Day of the Dove i'm VERY familiar with. I started out going from memory, using the transcript as a check.
I've never watched What You Leave Behind. Thats why I joined this thread so late. So I had to use the transcript. But I feel I have experienced the episode in a totally new way.
Its almost like reading a story, but not really.
If it's not how the game is played then I'll refrain from taking part in episodes I have not watched.
But I can say I think its good, clean fun!