LOKAI of CHERON wrote:
"Methinks the lady doth protest too much"
I managed to make 7 posts without saying which version was "inferior ---IMO"
But in your first post you managed to throw that in. Goody for you---thanks for letting us know where you stand.
No, I stated the alternate takes are inferior. Also, I managed to totally avoid going off the deep end and use insulting language about anybody else's posts for absolutely no reason.
Oh, by the way, this is a message board primarily used for people to express their opinions on Star Trek.
The alterate takes are indeed
inferior. About the only addition I quite like is the
"That young man is my son"
in the jeffries tube.
The rest don't really add much at all. I don't like the re-editing of the "rednax 5" scene, I'm not sure it needs all the stuff with Scotty's nephew and I hate the way that bones says "admiral, what about the rest of the inspection" in this version. It loses all the humour IMHO.
Oh, and I think Grant
totally overeacted IMHO.
IMHO of course