My Name Is Legion wrote:
That line is from Razor, which fans generally agree screwed the character beyond recognition anyway. I am judging the character by her Season 2 appearance.
Most fans do not "generally agree" to any such thing, and in any event you don't get to pick and choose which parts of nuBSG you get to ignore in order to hold your argument together.
Well, alright even if we have to count Razor it gives us the Adama defending Cain quote mentioned in the OP so I still win