Morpheus 02 wrote:
It was VERY vague to me, and I could see Carl's view.
I think you're supposed to. It's not like the youngster just dropped his gun immediately when ordered to. He saw a woman with a baby, an old crippled man & a little boy. He could have been getting ideas, & Carl probably decided he wasn't going to wait anymore
But you're also supposed to see Hershel's perspective too, & regardless if Carl was wrong or not, it nevertheless says a lot about who he's becoming, a kill or be killed man with little or no moral hesitation
Hershel & Rick are right to be concerned about that