View Single Post
Old March 19 2013, 03:31 AM   #17
Christopher
Writer
 
Christopher's Avatar
 
Re: TOS: Spock Must Die! by James Blish [SPOILERS]

rfmcdpei wrote: View Post
Is it necessarily? Modern Trek literature seems to have settled upon quantum entanglement as the mechanism by which telepathy works, but absent spooky action at a distance some sort of psionic radiation is necessary. Tachyons make as much sense as any other form, especially given the tendency in science fiction before Star Trek (Heinlein's Time for the Stars, say) to describe telepaths as able to communicate simultaneously across light-years and to distinguish between the mere material workings of the brain and the infinite powers of the mind.
But as I said, it's not so much the idea of tachyons being associated with thought that bothered me, but the really inane logic that was used to justify that idea -- that we don't store memories or imagine things in our own heads but send magic radar beams out to ping off them. If that's how it works, how can we imagine things that don't exist?


An apparently mysterious reality?
I don't understand.


That's what I thought. It's not a strong connection, I think.
What I mean is that it's not evidence that Duane was referencing Blish, just that they were both physics-savvy.


Sure, but for me, the Dalton recension of the Eurish language bit jumped out at me because in all of my readings, within Trek and without, Blish and Duane are the only two authors who have specifically mentioned the Dalton recension of Eurish. That, and the fact that it was Uhura who mentioned it, makes me seriously wonder.
Okay, if the reference is that specific, it might be an actual nod.


The thing I enjoyed the most about the book were the discussions of what happens to the "soul" during the transport process, and if the person who comes out of the transporter is truly the same as the person who enters it. I believe that is the first time such discussions occurred in Trek, although it wasn't the last. I must admit that if transporter technology ever becomes a reality, such concerns would definitely make me hesistate before having my atoms scattered all across the universe.
I don't think I'd share in those fears, but, well, we're far from developing transporter technology so I've no way to test them.
I had an idea a while back that offered some comfort on that point:

https://christopherlbennett.wordpres...nuity-of-self/


bullethead wrote: View Post
I really like the idea of the Klingons locking the Organians away, because it explains why they never show up again, especially when the Federation and Klingons have that war in DS9 season 5.
Except that's not something that needs to be explained, because "Errand of Mercy" itself provided all the explanation that was needed. The episode made it very clear that the Organians couldn't stand to have anything to do with corporeal beings and were extremely reluctant to take any action, only doing so as an extraordinary measure because it was the only way they could get the noisy kids off their lawn. Implicit in that is that they should not be expected to intervene again. After all, the way episodic TV was done back then, it was a given that the events of the episode would probably not be referenced again (even mentioning the "Organian Peace Treaty" in "The Trouble With Tribbles" was an unusual bit of continuity for the era), so Gene Coon inserted an explanation for that right in the episode.
__________________
Christopher L. Bennett Homepage -- Site update 4/8/14 including annotations for Rise of the Federation: Tower of Babel

Written Worlds -- My blog
Christopher is offline   Reply With Quote