I commend the guys for holding back and not beating the shit out of him when he dumped their food, even though they are contractually obligated not to fight.
Phillip would sooo fucking stomp his ass into the ground in an actual fight too; crazy as he may be, but he's a beast.
Also, it's not really worth even trying to interpret his nonsense in a logical way, but I don't see what so honourable or whatever about orchestrating his own exit. Ok, you behaved so badly on the island your own tribe forfeited the challenge just to get rid of you. Congratulations?