Comparing a work of Tolken to a work of Orci makes invalidates pretty much you ever have, and ever will do.
I struggled to even make out what this post means
as it's such a mess but I think I got it.
Tolkien is uh, dead. He didn't have any involvement with the movie.
So Jackson came up with that film all by himself?
No the majority of the film going audience aren't dumb as you so graciously put it. And seeing the Hobbit 5 times doesn't make you an intelligent discriminating viewer.