Caretaker is to all over the place for me to take seriously. Starfleet-Maquis conflict, lost in space, a banjo man, a farm and a bunch of 19th century white people dancing and singing around on an alien array, space elves and tomato red people with funny head dressings. Yeah Caretaker is too silly to take seriously.
If i had to rank them from best to worst it would be:
Encounter at Farpoint