Yes, they should not post and not the Buzz Killingtons whose sole contribution references markets, budgets, cinema climate, ticket sales and audience figures...
I agree that would be a much more entertaining to read.
Why can't we all post? Why can't we all offer our observations and facts in a thread? I'm pretty sure we're all big boys and girls here.
One of the reasons some folks have a hard time here is because they come in with an air of superiority and this notion that you can't like Star Trek 2009
and the other series and movies.
As far as traditional space battles go: I liked the battles in Star Trek
, TNG, DS9, Voyager
the Prime universe movies and the 2009 movie.