DS9 only got 10%!?!?!?!?!?
It was the show that could have just continued, thanks to the rich characters and the interesting times in which they would live following the war.
Unfortunately, much of it was dull.
As far as what series a new take should resemble? The original obviously. Abrams has proven that the right mix of action and character drama can be successful.
It needs to revolve around big heroes taming the wild frontier.