View Single Post
Old January 25 2013, 09:26 AM   #9
Mister Atoz
Mister Atoz's Avatar
Location: Los Angeles
Re: FAULTY - the two worst TOS remastering mistakes

Dear Boobatuba ~

You can pretend anything you like in terms of what you think Kirk sees on the screen, but the original version has much more impact because it cuts from Kirk looking at the screen in astonishment -- to the screen showing clearly what is happening with the Enterprise in imminent danger. In the new version, the whole thing is fuzzy, mushy, unclear. The new version makes it seem like he's saying "What the devil is going on?" in response to a fuzzy, non-working screen display!

For a first time viewer of the ep, the whole meaning of the edit has dramatically changed. It's a pretty important cut, too, because it leads up to Kirk ordering Spock to relieve Decker of command.


~ Mr Atoz

boobatuba wrote: View Post
Mister Atoz wrote: View Post
mistake 1

Doomsday: Kirk is on the Constellation and is getting his view screen working. Washburn says "Try it now, Captain." Kirk says "Yes I think...What the devil's going on?"

The error occurs here. In the original version, the cut to the view screen immediately shows the Enterprise firing at the Doomsday cone. That is what Kirk is reacting to.

In the remastered version, the view screen shows static interference on the screen FIRST, then it fades to the Enterprise and the cone. In the remastered cut, Kirk would not have any reason to say "What the devil's going on?" because he hasn't seen the Enterprise yet. Furthermore, the remastered version shows the screen with only the Enterprise in it, firing phasers, which weakens the logic of Kirk's reaction still further! Then later the cone comes into the screen view. Opinions on this? I think it hurts the scene a lot.
How do you know the sequence of events isn't as follows?

1. Viewscreen clears - Kirk sees Enterprise attacking weapon and reacts
2. Viewscreen shorts again back into "search" mode or whatever - camera perspective changes to viewscreen
3. Viewscreen again clears.

Calling this a "mistake" doesn't really wash for me. Kirk clearly sees SOMETHING and reacts, so obviously the viewscreen showed something, then fuzzed out again.
Mister Atoz is offline   Reply With Quote