I think Pine, Quinto and Urban were clearly recognizable as the characters. The rest was hit and miss.
Reconizable, yes, but I'm far from convinced that Quinto is this uncanny Nimoy look-alike and I wasn't even a fan of his performance.
Pine and Urban were great in their performances though.
The rest are pretty forgettable. Sulo did nothing, Chekov and Scotty were jokes and Uhura was the token female whose contributions rivaled TOS Uhura.