And Janeway's promotion to admiral for getting her crew home was silly.
Isn't that basically why Starfleet made Kirk an Admiral after his five year mission?
I don't think Janeway's command record would be anywhere near as distinguished as Kirk's. And as the character was written, as much as I enjoy Voyager, I really think a pysch evaluation should have removed her from command. Volatile mood swings and extreme inconsistency.
Out of universe of course, she was only promoted to give her a glorified cameo in a movie.