But that isn't Kirk, or McCoy or any of them.
Yes it is, infact they nailed it closer than I think any other group of people could have. And they weren't even obliged to do so for the film, but did so anyway, because Abrams cared enough to make that effort. Correction, they all cared enough to do so.
Yea, Pine did a believable interpretation of Kirk, that was different, but, fit the character well, but, Quinto and Urban did an excellent job of completely embodying Spock and McCoy
One Day I hope to be the Man my Cat thinks I am
Where are we going? And why are we in this Handbasket?