I havent read the thread, but the biggest nitpicks for me are:
NO LORE, instead we get fucking B4... the adult baby
NO TOMALOK, why?!?!?! FFS we end up with Donatra... even Sela would be better.
NO TNG WARBIRDS, perhaps the most badass alien ship design in Science-Fiction.
Add on top of that the general stupidity of the script & the utterly idiotic mad max shit in the Argo.