Yes, there should be a separate thread for Elementary. I started this as a Sherlock thread until Christopher changed the subject.
I tried one more episode of Elementary since people claimed the pilot was weak.
After a second viewing my opinion isn't any different. A lukewarm series with a good lead in Jonny Lee Miller. I won't be giving it a third chance. It's just doesn't grab you the way Sherlock does. It's too "American CSI-ish." There's nothing to captivate you about the characters and Liu is unremarkable. There were only a dozen actresses who would have made a half decent lead.