I grew up on The Only Series.
Trek's New Guise was good in a lot of ways, but I hated the perfect humans and early "surrender-monkey" Picard.
DS9 was better, and got more so the more it ripped off B5.
VOY had some good ideas, but was too uneven in execution.
Early Nu Trek just didn't work for me.
JJ Trek had excellent dialogue and characterization, and some awesome ideas - loved Sulu's sword! - but the plot made no sense whatsoever, and had too much slapstick.