Edit_XYZ wrote:
But it's more than that - when it comes to Sci.
|
Ah, here it comes. A discussion about the size of various Trekverse conflicts turns into your personal dislike of me.
For example - not so long ago, he was vocal regarding Data remaining dead - in order to keep the ~'integrity of the trek lit line'.
Now, if asked, Sci would almost certainly say bringing back Data was a good idea.
|
Nope. I've read
The Persistence of Memory, and while I quite liked it, I still disagree with the idea of bringing Data back. I also disagree with the idea of bringing Janeway back, though I haven't yet had the chance to read
The Eternal Tide.
I have always maintained that a resurrection can be done well and plausibly yet still be a bad idea simply by virtue of undermining the verisimilitude of the shared universe by making death seem temporary. While I quite enjoyed
The Persistence of Memory, I also think it is a perfect example of exactly that.