Star Trek is a show about a group of people that travel the stars.
So, it irritates me that we're just getting two movies from Jar Jar Abrams about heroes shooting at a baddie who has a doomsday device and a vendetta against the Federation. It seems repetitive and a complete waste of the precious little Star Trek I am able to get in the current time.
Then TMP is a waste of time to since its the Changeling meets 2001.
Really, it all in the execution. I'll watch 10 movies with similar plot elements if they're well done.