An image of someone in the brig in TOS is persuasive of not a damn thing - it was a common shot on the show.
Evidence that Harrison is Charlie Evans:
Evidence that Harrison is Evil Kirk:
That's leaving aside the nonsensical notion that in doing a film version of some TOS adversary Abrams would set up shots to resemble those on a fifty year-old TV episode and that the studio would choose one as the first production still to be released.
It's not Gary Mitchell, Charlie Evans, Harry Mudd, Garth of Izar, Gary 7 or Evil Kirk. Get over it and get on with it.