I think Singer's reboot is the future.
I love BSG to bits but I don't want to see what came before be continually watered down with more cancelled series and one off web series. BSG was a self contained story and what they had was gold. I don't really want it to be chipped away at anymore. Caprica had potential but it never grabbed me the way BSG did. Considering the way Syfy treats it I think best to leave it alone altogether. There won't be a unique situation again where a BSG spinoff will have the breathing room to do something bold and original.