View Single Post
Old December 17 2012, 06:00 PM   #52
Sci's Avatar
Location: Montgomery County, State of Maryland
Re: Essential Star Trek Novels That Even Non-Trekkers Should Read

JWolf wrote: View Post
Sci wrote: View Post
Drago-Kazov wrote: View Post
Articles ha way too much continuity for this list.
Articles is no worse than a typical episode of The West Wing in that regard; all of its continuity is stuff you don't have to have read to read AotF, and most of it is stuff you might not even realize is a reference to other books if you haven't read them.
This is supposed to be a list of books for non-trekkies to read. AoTF just doesn't work here. While it's a very good book, it's not for non-trekkies who have not read the books around it.
It is, again, a book that works just fine without other books. Most of the references to other books are ones you wouldn't even know refer to other books if you haven't read them.

Full Circle is again another book that doesn't work. It need the books before it to work.
Don't agree. It works fine on its own.

When you pick books for the list, remember, this is for non-trekkies and you have to say to yourself, they may not have read any of the books. So don't pick books (like Wildfire) that need other books read first in order to work better.
1. I'll pick whatever books I want, thank you very much; please don't issue orders.

2. So, when I read Wildfire, I had read, like, maybe one S.C.E. book before -- the first one. I was almost wholly unfamiliar with S.C.E., and I thought it was a beautiful, haunting book.

I would absolutely defend Wildfire's inclusion. In fact, I would defend it above several other novels in both my list and in the io9 article.
Democratic socialism is the hope of human freedom.
Sci is offline   Reply With Quote