View Single Post
Old December 17 2012, 08:01 AM   #9
J. Allen
Snuggle Master
J. Allen's Avatar
Location: United States
View J. Allen's Twitter Profile
Re: MLP:FiM S3 Episode 7 "Wonderbolts Academy": Grading and Discussion

Before I go into more discussion, I realized that I had forgot to thank Peach Wookiee, in my first post, for making this thread in lieu of my forgetfulness! Thanks, Peach!

Gep Malakai wrote: View Post
Santa Hooves wrote: View Post
Anyway, I like that they addressed Dashie's occasional recklessness by seeing how she would respond with another pony who was like her in almost every way.
I thought they were going somewhere completely different with that I expected Dash and Lighting Dust to become really good friends and that when the choice came down to the two of them in the finals (or some such thing), Dash would give up her spot for her new friend because she knows how much Wonderbolt training means. Given that I can often predict how episodes will turn out, I was surprised and pleased they went in a totally different direction with things.
Indeed, it was nice to see a change in resolution.
When Dash chose to leave on ethical grounds, I was happy to see it. See, I do believe Dash is a true Element of Loyalty, and while she can be brash, fickle, and boastful, she will still defend her friends in the end, and she did so here in such a great and meaningful way.

Chemahkuu wrote: View Post
I loved the episode, and the character growth for Rainbow Dash. We've been waiting for this story since the pilot and it went roughly how I expected it too.

The conclusion was short and could have been given a little longer to really do it properly but then 22 minutes leaves little room as we've seen plenty of times before.

Pinkie's abandonment issues from Party of One resurface but luckily not enough for her to go full Pinkamena but it was nice to see them tackle that again.

Spitfire has always been the Captain of the Wonderbolts, who as Gep pointed out are a semi-military squadron for Canterlot. We know next to nothing about her and always off-duty. She wasn't all that hard to believe this week, and the ending showed us the Spitfire we know when she loosened up a bit, so it's still her.

Nice way for them to include the mane6, very similar to their arrival in Sonic Rainboom and for essentially the same reason again. And just like that episode Rarity needs saving...

I loved the moment when Fluttershy, having been rescued, starts flying off and cue a very pissed off Flitter with her "why didn't you do that in the first place" expression.

But Lightening, borderline homicide of 5 other ponies, doesn't care in the slightest? we've had some real asshole antagonists in this show but a normal pony with that level of sociopathy? that's cold.

For now we know RD is a team captain, not officially accepted as a Wonderbolt so it leaves the door open for resolving that later.

But it does leave a serious question for the series as a whole. The promo's, and the production staff, go on about "a pony discovering her true destiny.".

Well, we have the leaked image showing a return to the Crystal Empire that has not happened yet that could still revisit the "Crystal Princess" line about Cadance, Rainbow Dash still not technically becoming a Wonderbolt and all the fore shadowing of something important in Twilight's future, but which one is it?
I'm excited to see what comes next. That said, I also agree with you about Lightning Dust. As I mentioned on EqD, she nearly kills 5 innocent ponies, and all she can muster is a "so what?" and harping on how awesome her record would have been? That's stone cold psycho pony material, right there.

Lightning Dust has major problems, and if that happened in a military organization, she would get kicked out, because that's a major red flag. No one would trust such a pony, and in an emergency, you have to trust the person that has your back. So to me, kicking her out was very reasonable. It was almost a slap on the wrist, all things considered!
Haven't been to Brony Kingdom in a while? We miss you! Visit our reunion thread!

-= St. John of Trenton, Patron Saint of Cute Ponies =-
Title Bestowed Upon Me by Pondwater
J. Allen is offline   Reply With Quote