All things considered, I'm voting this "Excellent". It certainly wasn't flawless. But it was fun, exciting, and I thoroughly enjoyed myself. The "cameo" was great. And while the ending felt rushed (Adama's acceptance), it nonetheless sets the stage for plenty of adventure in future installments (even if those installments are never realized). To say that there's NO dramatic tension if Adam is the main character is too narrow a view, IMO. For starters, this show is less about "tension" and more about action and entertainment. To that extent, I see a great deal of potential - if the miraculous happens and the series sees another installment.