Well, I recently rented Saints Row 3.
The bright spot for me was the music. And that's about it.
My main gripes:
1. In the Matrix trilogy, Neo would fight one, then a larger group, then a whole army of Agent Smiths. That's what I felt was happening in this game.
2. The graphics weren't great. There were clipping issues. The characters, for me, weren't attractive.
3. I didn't understand what the map was telling me. I started in one area, and over time that area became more purple. Did that mean I was claiming land, or was I losing land?
I didn't get pass the first two missions, before deciding this game wasn't for me. This game, and the game I rented before, Call of Duty: Black Ops II left me feeling meh. I am hoping that the next game is more enjoyable.