I'll certainly give this a shot.
I too was hopeful that gandt would be more focused on the novels, but even when they reviewed a story, they didnt really go into much detail...and alot of their arguments tend to devolve into bashing of star trek online. i've never played STO so it really just turned me off. I did appreciate their cast of the review of Star Trek Las Vegas, but the overall ideal of novel discussion tended to fall by the wayside. It could also have used some editing to cut down on their mechanical problems that got broadcast...as it stands, the podcast is very raw without any edits. But, i say everyone should give it a shot, it just might be their cup of tea. Certainly it takes a ton of work to produce a podcast, and they are passionate about the material.