Initially I voted just for Option 3 (the metal shield) as it's clean and consistent with TOS & TNG Blu ray.
But added a second tactical vote to Option 2 (the crashing & burning starship).
Anything to deny Option 1 (shee-aye-ta photoshop) from winning!
There damn-well isn't much in this race though...
If it had gone with more cast variety, I suspect 3 would be doing a lot better.
Seems to be an acceptance for substandard art, so long as it's inclusive of crew, ship and icon.
It's the "Cake and Eat It" Option.