It's got to be the third one for me. With the metallic patch, lens flares and Captain Archer into darkness at the side.
▼
Although maybe they could change it to incorporate other cast members?
Having done Archer on S1...
Say Phlox & Mayweather for S2, Hoshi & Reed for S3 and then Trip & T'Pol for S4?
Positioned top & bottom, in the space Bakula occupies, facing off to the left also.
Second option with the fiery NX-01 is certainly lovely artwork. But it's all the same. Just flipped and tinted different colours.
▼
I'd avoid the first option like the plague. Uninspired. Recycled publicity shots.
▼