View Single Post
Old October 28 2012, 03:31 AM   #35
Vice Admiral
Maurice's Avatar
Location: Maurice in San Francisco
View Maurice's Twitter Profile
Re: how big an improvement is the star trek motion picture director cu

gottacook wrote: View Post
Maurice wrote: View Post
Kirk didn't want "to see the band get back together." He "used this emergency to get the Enterprise back." That's all he wanted: to command a starship again. [...] He's perfectly in character throughout.
Sure, but that's the trouble - of course Kirk would take advantage of the emergency to regain command of the Enterprise, else there'd be no movie! That is to say, any possible screenplay for a TMP written some years after the end of the TV series would (almost by definition) have to focus on an emergency situation that gets the gang back together, with ol' Jim in command.

The problem with any of the present versions of TMP is that it's just so rote in this respect. Any mechanism, no matter how inventive and enterprising, for getting the crew back together on their starship would in retrospect seem unexciting, the "deaths" of the guest stars notwithstanding (and irrespective of whether Vulcan has a moon).
Grant wrote: View Post
...perhaps, but not the character anybody wanted to see.
I simply pointed out that mos6507 was incorrect about Kirk wanting "to see the band get back together." That you both think it was the wrong dramatic decision has no bearing on whether Kirk was acting in character given the story setup.
* * *
“Tact is the ability to tell someone to go to hell in such a way that they look forward to the trip.”
― Winston S. Churchill
Maurice is online now   Reply With Quote