Another positive review here.
(I don't think it's very popular on this board because I don't think there are many J/C fans here, for one thing.)
One of my favourite episodes. Anything else aside, it's so nice to see them get a chance to actually get to know each other as something other than Captain and First Officer - and even if it didn't lead to romance, I've always thought it cemented the deep friendship they shared throughout the series.
And, c'mon, he built her a bathtub
. I'm sure some of my cavities are from the number of times I've watched this episode.