Greg Cox wrote:
What are you going to do, rejuvenate Shatner or Stewart? Or do you really want a bunch of kids playing them?.
Why not? Classic characters can always be recast . . . .
Because no one can act like Stewart or Shatner no matter how many manerisms they try to replicate. I'd never buy it, just like I didn't nuKirk. It was just alien to me.
PS. Those were all movies, and no continuity movies at that. When you see Picard in almost 200 episodes, it's a bit different from replacing shambolic Cloney with serious actor like Bale. Comic books vs Star Trek is too much like apples and oranges