View Single Post
Old September 30 2012, 07:18 AM   #10
Re: TNG episodes that would've been interesting to see on TOS

Wingsley wrote: View Post
I like to think that TNG's "The Survivors" actually spoke in a decidedly TOS tone. That show was strongly reminiscent of TOS. To an extent, so did "Where Silence Has Lease" (written by Jack Sowards, who I believe was involved in TMP2) and also "Up the Long Ladder", "The Enemy", "The Defector" and "First Contact", as well as DS9's "The Search" two-parter.

The ultimate retcon job would be to imagine "Yesterday's Enterprise", very patently a TNG story, as a TOS story. While it might be interesting to imagine an earlier Starship Enterprise (maybe Archer's NX-01?), it would work to see any early Federation Starship (maybe the Valiant?) accidentally skipping forward in time and altering history in the process. Imagine if the fifty-year-old U.S.S. Valiant had not been destroyed at Eminiar VII, but instead the intensity of the battle in the Eminiar system accidentally threw the Valiant forward in time... into either Klingon or Romulan space... triggering a major incident. If the Valiant wouldn't work, it might be interesting to see an older, prototype Enterprise, NX-1701, having been called into service for either the Battle of Axanar or the Battle of Donatu V, and the battle's energy expenditure threw the Enterrpise's older self forward... to meet either an Enterprise-A or Kirk commanding some other Connie on behalf of some beleaguered, diminished Federation whose members are at odds with each other.

(A thought just occurred to me: the earlier NX-1701 Enterprise could have been thrown forward minimally damaged, only to encounter and rescue the Valiant-A, a Coalition of Planets starship commanded by Spock, himself a Coalition flag officer with a human XO named Kirk. Spock is concerned about fleet maneuvers to head off a Romulan invasion, when the early-Enterprise suddenly flies in from Klingon space after riling the Klingons. Now Captain Robert April must decide if his duty is to report to Spock and help repel the invasion, or to go back in time to face the Eminian music and probably die.
The Yesterday's Enterprise stuff sounds kind of convoluted, but The Survivors would indeed fit in on TOS nicely. Would've been neat for them to find some old-time actor to deliver Kevin Uxbridge's haunting confession.

One wonders if they could've done a show like Cause and Effect. You just know the Enterprise blowing up in the teaser would've shocked the hell out of a 60's audience. I wonder what their idea of a Starfleet ship a century older than the Constitution class would look like. (Notice I was careful not to say a 22nd Century ship, since they never did peg down the century on the original series. I believe as late as the writer's bible for the Star Trek II series, they were being intentionally vague). Would've been neat if they could've gotten a well-known actor from some popular show on at the time to cameo as the captain of the other ship, as Kelsey Grammer did.

Conundrum is another one that I think would've worked.

Half of The Enemy might work, with someone like Scotty stranded on a hostile planet, forced to work with together. (Actually, a movie called "Hell in the Pacific", which came out in 1968, dealt with a very similar scenario). With the Worf giving blood part, however, I can't think of anyone on the show that could assume that role.

The Royale might've been doable. I could see Kirk reading Col. Richey's final log. Would've loved to see Spock clean out the casino.

Darmok DEFINITELY would work!

It's hard to imagine Kirk not hooking up with Kamala (or her liking who she is around him, as she did with Picard), so The Perfect Mate probably wouldn't work.

I wasn't particularly a fan of Up the Long Ladder
t_smitts is offline   Reply With Quote