This sounds a lot like "orange is a superior color to green" discussion.
Another example of generic vs. effective.
The space battles in Wrath of Khan and the space battle in Nemesis.
In Wrath of Khan, there are three moments where the ships exchange fire. Three. And very short as well. Khan's first surprise attack and Kirk's comeback. Then Khan's attack in the Mutara Nebula that destroys the torpedo bay and the Enterprise fires back. And then Kirk's attack that destroys the warp nacelle of the Reliant. And yet these are powerful stuff.
In Nemesis, hundreds of torpedoes and phaser beams are thrown around. People are thrown around in their chairs. And the battle goes on and on. Nothing very memorable. The battle as a whole, yeah, but the events inside the battle... nah.
It's a quality over quantity thing, wouldn't you say?
This doesn't sound like a fan film discussion to me...
Discussion about filmmaking is useful for making fan films.