I'd think Broken Bow is the best pilot of all the series.
TNG: Beyond terrible, embarrassing.
DS9: I found it personally meaningful but really it's a bit clunky.
VOY: Anything with a banjo loses major points. Exciting in it's own way though.
Broken Bow is just a much tighter package than the others IMO.
What do you have against Banjos. They were on a farm so the whole idea of the old "banjo" man made sense in the context.