As I've posted before I don't want her back as a Q, I want her as a real flesh and blood coffee drinking woman. There are enough super beings in Trek Land and they're all a tad dull IMHO compared to real people. Ideally I'd like her back changed.. by the trauma of everything that has happened to her, though Treklit isn't too great at that kind of character arc. If she and Chak must be torn apart
let it be because assimilation and death mess with your head, LOL.
I just want to see her returned and staying returned, no return just to sacrifice herself crap. I don't care if she's an admiral, a civilian, with Chak, without Chak, the main character of every VOY book to come or lost in some dusty ambassador post. Just be alive.