Let's be fair, Roy's almost certainly going to start with Gerrard and Lampard, with Parker most likely holding behind them.
Given that, I'd rather take the additional striker. Defoe's not been playing much, so I'd play him the friendlies to start with. The problem without Defoe is that there's very little experience there. Plus Walcott's likely to start on the right of midfield.
Just wonder if Roy will be tempted to pick Carroll?