View Single Post
Old April 10 2012, 01:35 AM   #814
Sci
Admiral
 
Sci's Avatar
 
Location: Hoping for a left-wing Westminster
Re: Ongoing Community Discussion Thread

Admiral_Young wrote: View Post
What's wrong with the nominating a fan film series?
Let me put it this way:

Should the Nobel Committee nominate a work of fan fiction in a field that's competing against professional literature? No, of course not.

Would you put a fan-written and produced sequel to Les Miserables up for a Tony? No, of course not.

Because the standards of quality are completely different, and because it's inappropriate to nominate an unauthorized, unlicensed work of fiction based upon someone else's copyrighted work up against original copyrighted work.

If the Hugos want to be in the business of nominating fan films, or CGI characters' awards acceptance skits, they should create a "Best Fan Film Installment" category, and a "Best Genre Short" or "Best Genre Skit" category.
__________________
Democratic socialism is the hope of human freedom.
Sci is offline   Reply With Quote