It sounds like this has mostly been a success. If we're both still around next year, we might do something similar. No promises!
A lot of the requests we got were also followed with a thank you for doing this, and everyone has shown appreciation in this thread as well. I don't do things expecting to be thanked for them, so that's been a very pleasant surprise. You guys are a great bunch and I'd like to wish each of you a Happy Valentine's Day. You all mean a lot to me.