Look, Admiral Shran is picking away Shattered, one of my alltime favourite episodes, but he doesn`t like it. Well, it`s his decision.
That's how I've always assumed these games are supposed to be played. You slowly pick away at your least favorite remaining episode until it's been eliminated while slowly building up your favorites. If someone disagrees with you on an episode, it adds to the fun.
I had a Babylon 5
hurt/heal game going a while back. It literally took me dozens of attempts to eliminate one episode I didn't particularly care for because so many other people liked it.
Oh, and it's not that I don't like Shattered
. I *kind of* like it. But the Seska sub-plot really harms it IMO.