Chris3123 wrote:

Guartho wrote:

Chris3123 wrote:

And both were the Ninth Doctor. That rules out either matching with Jack's timeline, since 9 regenerated right after Jack last saw him.
|
Yes, but Jack should have had no way of knowing that.
|
True, though my point was more that they weren't the Doctor Jack was looking for, rather than whether he would know.
|
9 should be the one Jack is looking for since he should be unaware of 9's regeneration into 10.
And yes, we absolutely are over thinking it, but I think it's ok if you do it knowingly and just for fun.