milo bloom wrote:
Even as a big fan of RDM's take, now I'm slightly less onboard with this. I guess I could see a First Cylon War situation being doable, but sometimes I think it's fine to just have something stand on it's own.
Of course, all BSG products can fit together under the "all this has happened before and will happen again" banner, but I don't want to see them forcing something that shouldn't be forced.
Really, they tied nuBSG in with oldBSG through some visual stylistic things - mainly whenever they'd recreate events from the first Cylon War they'd use oldBSG designs or variations of same. People liked that, in the main, although there was really no logical way to make the continuities mesh in that time-frame. So if something similar is done with the movie I'm sure folks will appreciate it, chuckle and move on.