View Single Post
Old September 24 2011, 02:10 PM   #72
Maximara
Lieutenant Junior Grade
 
Location: Las Cruces, NM
Re: Kirk and the Prime Directive.

Hartzilla2007 wrote: View Post
Maximara wrote: View Post
Uxi wrote: View Post
I think the worst part about TNG is that they never revisited some of the former planets TOS went to, precisely to see what happened to them and perhaps show a different pov on the necessity of the actions taken by TOS. Piece of the Action, etc would have been most interesting.

They also dropped the Preservers/parallel development angle entirely, which could have been good. And instead of aliens using the Paramount period wardrobe (Romans, Nazis, etc) they went to the forehead widget. Ah well.
Star Trek Unlimited #10 Jul 1998 (A piece of reaction) showed just why the show didn't go back to worlds Kirk had visited--it made the TNG Federation look more idiotic than in Kirk's time.

"Think we should at least check up on that planet Kirk messed with over the next 100 years?"
"Nah, what is the worse that can happen?"

For the story have any meaning the Federation would have not done any follow up since Kirk's time and that was ridiculous.
Which is wierd since Kirk's compromise to get the natives to stop the Mobs wars included a federation starship visiting the planet I believe once a year.
Which is par for the course as various details from TOS got lost in TNG.

For example in Where Silence Has Lease Data states "There is no record of any Federation vessel encountering anything remotely like this" despite the fact Captain Kirk encountered just such an area of blackness in The Immunity Syndrome which fits the "old Klingon legend a gigantic black space creature which was said to devour entire vessels" Worf relates perfectly.

It is one of the blunders that make you wonder just how competent the Federation really is.
Maximara is offline   Reply With Quote