^ Sorry, I meant to say Arkham Asylum. But based on your response I presume you already played that.
I can see how RDR wouldn't be for everyone. I personally loved it.
I got it because it had such rave reviews, and I really enjoyed the GTA games on PS2. I just don't think I am a fan of the western genre.
It's okay, though. My roommate stole it and played it for weeks on end, so it got its money's worth.