Never liked Routh as Superman, personally.
Anyway, I'm not 100% sold on the suit. I'm not exactly against it either but it's not exactly "blowing my skirt up" so to speak.
I still think the red "briefs" part should be there or at least something more of color in the waist area and the ribbing and texturing on it makes it look just too busy. Nor do I like the alligator skin look of it. I also think his, um, "area" is over emphasized.
It's looks decent enough, I suppose, but I think it could have been done better.