Isn't that sad?
Wanting a fav character to remain "dead"/AWOL just because dead is better than character assasination?
I know what you mean about "not trusting"... and in fact that idea was raised in the previous thread that Janewayites should "be careful what they wished for", because the person brought back may bear only a superficial resemblence to our Beloved Captain.
And that's what's really sad.
The worry that small people with mean hearts would bring her back to "teach us" a lesson. And once they assassinate her good character and the legion of fans abandon the books, they can then POINT to our flight as evidence "we" were never a large enough audience to cater to in the first place.
I guess its time to find another Admiral Janeway
story worth writing.