I voted excellent.
Except for the god aweful CGI and TW appearrantly not wanting to be seen as Superman in the suit, I thought it ended the way it was supposed to.
As for all the bitching and moaning that has gone on, "C'mon man!!! This is "Smallville", NOT the New New Adventures of Superman"!
For all those that condemn the episode that haven't been faithful viewers through all
10 seasons is just full of utter BS.
I went into this show cautious of all the news I read about it ( NTNF, Clark and Lex becoming "BBF's"...etc.) that I have always thought it was a kind of "Elseworlds" take on the mythos. And do know what?...it worked.