How did I miss this the first time around? (Or did I? Too lazy to check.)
Tahmoh is too Frankensteinian for my tastes and Ackles is a bit too girly looking, but I'd say he's just this side of too girly, so he gets a pass. And as Dorian
so sagely points out, the girly-men do have the advantage that age sometimes solves the problem...
I'll have to do another one of my Hottest Men of SF/F polls again someday...maybe when the new fall season starts. With any luck, we might have some worthy contenders in that crop. The situation is too bleak right now to bother with.