Like I said when Trek Remastered was being considered - I enjoy seeing new effects in NEW productions, and I enjoy seeing people like us messing around with desktop CGI creating cool new effects of old favorites, I do NOT want to see original shows disfigured with new effects in any official way.
The problems is that a new higher resolution media come out (DVD,Blu-ray etc) the quality or lack there of in the original effects will become more and more apparent.
The older I get the more apparent it becomes too.
If new audiences have problems accepting the way things were when a show was made, that's their
problem, not the show's.
It's the "colorizing Casablanca" discussion.