Her performance there had two settings (on a range of 1-10): 1 and 15.
I'd agree that Blaylock could be very hit and miss as T'pol. One episode she'd hit it out-of-the-park and the next would be a foul tip out to the catcher.
Sorry but if we're going with the baseball metaphors, for Blalock it was either striking out swinging or striking out looking.
if she was hitting them out of the park it must've been during batting practice.
You guys are channelling
My vote is for Nana Visitor, something about her voice just makes me want to perforate my eardrums.